14 Comments
User's avatar
Ciarra K. Walters's avatar

Thank you for this. The ending paragraph is sticking to me 💭

Expand full comment
Michelle Soslau's avatar

This is the heart of the whole “thing”. ❤️

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Thank you, Michelle!

Expand full comment
Linda Cassidy's avatar

This is a really important line of inquiry Carter, thank you for pursuing it. It's also a beautifully designed essay I happen to "like."

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Thank you, Linda, for your comment on form as well as content.

Expand full comment
Nola Zirin's avatar

Yes what is so important about liking art “

Excellent understanding of the very complexity of early abstract expressionists.

Thank you for sharing your knowledge and insight.

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Thank you, Nola

Expand full comment
George's avatar

The answer is Yes! yes yes yes.

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Indeed, yes . . .

Expand full comment
Christopher Quirk's avatar

"....Mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.

Now Ireland has her madness and her weather still,

For poetry makes nothing happen: it survives

In the valley of its making where executives

Would never want to tamper, flows on south

From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs,

Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives,

A way of happening, a mouth"

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Auden is convincing, if not demonstrably right about poetry's power to make anything happen, and yet I feel that he, too, carried on as if it could, despite everything, have a good effect on the world.

Expand full comment
Christopher Quirk's avatar

I agree and think evidenced by Auden's hortatory (if also somber) third section of the poem, and its frantic, runaway meter. Also that he says "makes nothing happen" rather than something like "is not important" seems very considered. But, yes can think of revolutionary poets who were at least a part of making things happen, like Petõfi for one and I'm sure I'm missing more obvious examples.

Expand full comment
Steven Siegel's avatar

What enabled Guston to "address the world beyond the haven of one’s sensibility" so, so well is that he had a fully developed and even sublime sensibility. Few artists preoccupied with meaning do, and their "statements" often fall flat. What Guston communicated could not be written in an op-ed.

Thanks for writing this.

Expand full comment
Carter Ratcliff's avatar

Yes, Guston was not making statements but, from the depths of his often tormented sensibility, conveying important meanings.

Expand full comment